Unfortunately, these Ethanol & Oxygenator additions to Petrol are chemically aggressive and have a tendancy to infiltrate and attack the Rubber compounds
historically used to make fuel hosing, 'O' rings and accelerator pump diaphragms.   These rubber components perish, swell and crack under the influence
of Ethanol and ultimateley fail in their function.
Picture of perished hose end courtesy of "coopersim" on the Volkszone forum
Weeping fuel lines can cause FIRES.!
There is a lot of anecdotal evidence on Internet Forums and increasing quantities of formal Technical Reports supporting this viewpoint;   In both Automotive and Light Aviation user groups.
A report from QinetiQ (The old Defence Evaluation & Research Agency, DERA) has been published highlighting these concerns in relation to Light Aviation where MoGas (ordinary Petrol Station Petrol) is used
Click here to read the QinetiQ report
In terms of selecting an appropriate fuel hose for our classic cars we need to understand where the competing Standards of commercial fuel hose come from:
As an Automotive specific standards body exists then we automatically have to make sure products conform to their standards for sale into the Automotive sector - this cover issues of liability.   Though we could later cross-reference the other
Standards to cross-sell into other fields such as Marine and General Aviation (MoGas Users).   There is usually a high degree of overlap between Standards from these differing sectors as they do feed off each other somewhat.
The specific SAE Standard for fuel conveying hoses is SAE J30, which can be broken down into its individual sub-regulations as follows;   The full SAE J30 specification can be downloaded by clicking here
  |
Title |
  Permitivity   |
  Working Pressure   |
Notes |
R2 |
Synthetic Rubber Tube And Cover Hose |
N/A |
N/A |
Oil & Ozone Resistant |
R3 |
Braided Reinforced Rubber Hose |
N/A |
N/A |
Petrol, Oil & Water Resistant |
R5 |
Wire Reinforced Rubber Hose |
N/A |
N/A |
Oil & Ozone Resistant |
R6 |
Low Pressure Synthetic Rubber Hose |
600 g/m²/day |
50 PSI |
Inner Resistant To Petrol, Diesel, Oil Or Vapours Ozone & Heat Resistant Outer |
R7 |
Low Pressure Synthetic Rubber Hose |
550 g/m²/day |
50 PSI |
Inner Resistant To Petrol, Diesel, Oil Or Vapours Ozone & Heat Resistant Outer |
R8 |
Low Pressure Synthetic Rubber Hose |
200 g/m²/day |
50 PSI |
Inner Resistant To Petrol, Diesel, Oil Or Vapours Ozone & Heat Resistant Outer |
R9 |
Fuel Injection Synthetic Rubber Hose |
15 g/m²/day |
100 PSI |
Inner Resistant To Chemical Attack, Swelling, And Permeation By Gasoline, Oxidized ("Sour") Gasoline, Ethanol
Extended Gasoline, Diesel Fuel, And Oil Or Lubricants Or Vapours. Oil, Ozone & Heat Resistant Outer |
R10 |
Low Pressure In-Tank (Submersed) Hose |
N/A |
N/A |
  |
R11 |
Low Permeation Fuel Fill, Vent, and Vapor Hose |
100 g/m²/day |
N/A |
Inner Resistant To Petrol, Diesel, Oil Or Vapours Ozone & Heat Resistant Outer |
R12 |
Low Permeation Fuel Feed & Return Hose |
100 g/m²/day |
145 PSI |
  |
R13 |
Diesel / Bio-Disesl Hose |
N/A |
N/A |
Under Development |
R14 |
Low Pressure Hose (Small Engines) |
15 g/m²/day |
50 PSI |
Other Characteristics As Per R9 Spec. |
The general evolution of the hose Standard can be seen; Higher numbers representing the latest generation of Standard.   Though the gradings are not entirely linear; R12 is not necessarily better than an R10 grade as the two hose standards cover different application zones.
The R6/7/8 Standards represent the drive to cut vapour emissions on carburatted cars in the 1980s & 1990s, with the R9 Standard building on this to cater for the introduction of fuel injection and bio-enhanced fuels.
It can be seen that R9 fuel hose that has been DESIGNED to work with modern fuels has less than 3% of the permitivity of 1980s & 1990s fuel hose.   It even out performs the "A1" (ISO 7840) hosing mandated for use in the MARINE environment, where they are hugely stringent about fire-safety.! (See graph below)
The R6 & R12 data-points being from a reputable manufacturers data sheets; This shows that manufacturers try to EXCEED the Standard where possible.
The fuel injection grades of fuel hose (R9 & R12) are backward compatible with low-pressure carburatted cars.   This and the exceptionally resistance to chemical attack, swelling and permeation of the R9 grade makes this grade ideal for use in the classic car sector.
The high permitivity of older fuel hoses means that as the bio-Ethanol content of Petrol rises that the older grades of fuel hosing will rot/perish/crack/weep at an increasingly quickening rate from the point of installation. This is because the escaping vapours 'wash out' the synthetic rubber compounds
that help keep the fuel hose supple - the ensuing brittleness enables cracks to develop in the hose.
Picture of perished hose end courtesy of "coopersim" on the Volkszone forum
The Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) in the United Kingdom has issued a Mandatory Permit Directive (MPD) on Trelleborg "Hydro K" fuel hoses, mandating an elevated level of service checks on this type of fuel hose due to evidence of perishing in the above manner.
Click here to read the CAA MPD
Is it worth putting your (expensive) Camper Van at risk of catching fire for the sake of some fuel hosing..? The SAE J30 R9 hosing is WELL WORTH the investment for the peace of mind it gives.
|